Marines in europe ww2 reddit. Or check it out in the app stores .
Marines in europe ww2 reddit There's even pictures, maps, etc. And Europe and the Atlantic only got a fraction of of the Naval allotment of the Pacific. Take a look at the Media and Video games: Marines What are the most interesting and niche WW2 historical sites to visit in Europe? I am talking Mark Felton level historical sites (Wansee Villa, Soviet Demarcation line, etc). 3rd ID took over 25,000 battle casualties (Not killed, it includes wounded). Then as mentioned, guerrilla warfare and advanced mobilization skew these numbers. If you're a Nazi though, fuck off. Or check it out in the app stores I’ve heard it said that the European theater of WW2 was a war whereas the pacific was just a meat grinder Shawn Ryan on YouTube has an interview with a flamethrower marine from ww2. They also would have LVTs or landing vehicle tracked for transport ashore. We thought he was a marine but since there weren't a lot of marine deployments, then he most likely wasn't a marine. 00 prior to September 1942) per The Germans did not, in fact, start WWII with more submarines than the Allies. Army went head to head with the most advanced military at the time. There were small detachments of Marines aboard the battleships that bombarded the Normandy coast on D-Day and some Marines even expressed a willingness to go ashore and assist the Rangers at Pointe We think of the U. You aren't completely wrong about Marines "fighting" in Europe, however. The Maines were primarily used in the Pacific. A large percentage of their infantry divisions served in the Pacific, and the first offensive combat conducted in WWII by the US Army was in the Pacific by the 164th Infantry Regiment on Guadalcanal in October 1942. The American approach is all the more bizarre when you consider that a large part of the British 14 th Army in South East Asia was made up of colonial soldiers including two African infantry divisions. S. 1st, 4th, 9th Marines were sent almost exclusively to the Pacific theater, due to their focus on amphibious warfare and the island-hopping nature of that fight. They were 'quite animated', noted a corporal who assumed they were playing a game of craps. The Monroe Doctrine, put forward in 1824, told European powers that the Americas were our playground and they could all go get stuffed. Now I know that the Marines where the corner stone of Yes there were many marines fighting in the ETO: " A total of nine battalions of RM Commandos were raised during World War 2, numbered from 40 to 48. Canadian units took part in a number of major actions, and many significant battles in Europe were Canadian ones. Finally, WW2 had a period of "lull" in terms of major fighting. We really don't know much about this man but we are trying to piece together a few things. The first two battalions would take on a unique character and organization based on the personalities of their commanders: Marine's Marine Merritt Edson and Sinophile Evans Carlson. Taiwan Marines are part of the Navy. The French have the Marines as part of the Army and the Naval Fusiliers which are part of the Navy. Colorized by me WW2 Era Booklet Given to All Troops Processing Through Camp Kilmer After Returning From The War in Europe. We have never been non-interventionist. This relationship brought my uncle. Not sure as far as historically accurate for marines in Europe during ww2. com Open. Locked due to reddit protests, until the 14. Even once in mainland Europe your training never stopped. The main German resistance centred on the old fort of St Nicolas. Fort Bragg has a monument on base remarking that the last shot fired in the Europe theater by US Forces came Yes, Marines aren't as equipped as a standard U. A Merchant Marine is entirely different. I got to see an exhibit about the internment in Hawaii during WW2 at the Nisei Veterans Memorial Center in Maui and it was absolutely heart breaking. Marines as spearheading the pacific campaign, but I had heard that the Army dedicated 25% of their forces to the pacific and 75% to the European theater. The average American private soldier who was single made a base pay of $50. A lot of folks kind of have a fetish for Marines Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Ironically, the Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. What we know for sure is that the thing is unreliable in Korea and it lacks stopping power with Marines saying that most the kills 146K subscribers in the ww2 community. 139K subscribers in the ww2 community. Or check it out in the app stores Found under a picture of US marines in the Pacific during WW2 Share Add a Comment. Hard to forget the largest battle the USA fought in ww2 was the battle of the bulge, which was a mere fraction of the horrors of Yeah there were no Marines fighting in the European theater, leading to the old Army joke of reminding Marines that there were no Marines present at the largest amphibious landing in history. We had to learn this in a class called Corps History actually The Corps of Royal Marines (RM) are part of the Royal Navy and not an independent unit, however are organised into a Light Infantry Brigade (3 Commando Brigade, the only surviving commando brigade after WW2). Luckily for the Arcelin, he was wearing the uniform of Sgt. Language barrier in occupied europe in WW2 . (I say about because Ask Europeans questions about their countries! Advertisement Coins. He said some of the guys they would fight out of the 131K subscribers in the USMC community. How did the people, both civilian and military, deal with the language barrier in the occupied territories of europe during World War 2? I actually translated in Iraq I spent a little over 3 years there 2008-2011 while in the marines my mother is Chaldean(Catholics from Iraq) so Arabic is my Look at WW2. . It didn’t make much sense to ship the Marines to Europe. By way of other figures, your typical WW2 infantry division consisted of about 14,000 men, of whom about 4,000 were infantry. The US Forces in Europe awaiting D-Day continuously trained for the fight in Europe. The country had virtually no navy, still, they created a marine corp to be the troops for the few ships they operate. At Germany's surrender the US had around 66-68 Army divisions in Europe, and 28 combined Army and Marine divisions in the Pacific. The Marine Corps. Or check it out in the app stores it was statistically impossible for a flight crew to finish a 25-mission tour in Europe warbirdsnews. Or check it out in the app stores It's so hard to find WW2 stories of Marines in Europe. They do not fight hand to hand. Official Unofficial USMC forum for anything Marine Corps related. The US Army sent around 73,000 soldiers to Normandy and only accounted for roughly 20% of the Normandy invasion. There was no need to have some marines or navy squadron of aicrafts operating there. Spearheading the Marine's offensive efforts in 1942-43 were the Marine Corps own commando unit: the four Marine Raider Battalions. I tried to find that passage in my paperback copy of Delivered From Evil earlier Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. As the war progressed, the M1 became more ubiquitous and replaced most of the M1903s. It was considered at some point to strike V-1 launch sites using F4Us from the US marine corps equipped with "Tiny Tim" rockets but it went nowhere some say for inter-service rivarly, some because the Tiny-Tim wasn't quite ready yet in mid '44. The marines frequently got second tier material, and the European theater was given priority over the Pacific. So by the time the US went on the offensive the IJA had an image of an enemy that was inaccurate. On the flip side you had the Japanese viewing everyone that wasn't them as human shaped cattle. In the Second World War what was the Japanese soldiers opinion of United States Marines? They are not technically a part of the Navy, but back then the Marines was still regarded as “the Navy’s infantry”. The same for Spanish, Filipino, Indonesian, Chinese marines. Time of service or having a chieldren would give you points, and those with more points would get home first. Maj. Axis godstomp. Boardman. WW2 was considered a much more “honorable” war than anything we might see today. For reference about 16,000,000 Americans served in uniform during WW2. So, whatever task required some boats and some soldier, it would be all led by the navy to prevent confusion, using navy ships and navy troops. Or check it out in the app stores in this book but it offers a pretty good look into Japan’s assessment and thinking as it related to the US prior to WW2. There were political and Army driven movements a few times to get rid of the Marines, or to get rid of aircraft carriers once the USAF came around. The USMC was also some of their own best PR people, after WW1, and then doubly so after WW2 they made sure the public knew plenty about their contributions and warrior ethos. See every Dawn of War game, arguably Helsreach (although there was also a LOT of guard there so maybe it gets a pass), the Horus Heresy (I believe the Horus Heresy has Space Marines using hundreds of thousands of marines to capture entire planets, which is orders of magnitude less soldiers then fought in WW2 alone), the Ultramarines seemingly 126K subscribers in the USMC community. Or check it out in the app stores After ww2 the Greek army sent few to serve in the US marines for the experience so Greece to improve the army. Embassy and diplomatic security. The best resource for understanding how the U. From Mass Observation records we can see that British people knew about the segregation in America, but it was difficult to apply to Britain due to their being such a small non-white population before the war, and even then was heavily concentrated in a few port cities TIL American soldiers in the Pacific theater of WW2 always used passwords containing the letter 'L' due to Japanese mispronunciation, a word such as lollapalooza would be used and upon hearing the first two syllables come back US Marine Corps soldiers on Bougainville in 1944 wearing the well known Frogskin camouflage. The Marine Division was not well suited to European combat, or would only be so with major US Army augmentation in categories like armor, anti-armor Legend has it that after the battle of Belleau Woods during the First World War the Imperial German Army soldiers who fought the U. I seem to recall reading a passage in Robert Leckie's one-volume history of WWII, Delivered From Evil, where Leckie succinctly sets out the age difference between US Marines and US Army soldiers in WWII: the Marines were approximately 19 years old; the soldiers were approximately 24 years old. Marine Corps paratroopers, they were not used in Europe. I am traveling for a few months this summer and want to go see as many WW2 sites as possible and this is most likely the only time I could try to do this. Marine divisions fought with distinction during WWI in France, so the tradition of being in the fight was there too. Before we get to that, though, it would be worth pushing back on your assumption above -- there was not a clear Army/Marine divide in the way that you describe; the US Army did the bulk of the ground fighting in the Pacific during World War II. There were very few Marines in the European Theater of Operations, serving mostly in non-combat roles such as advisors and fire watchers, along with a few Marines that worked with the OSS Posted by u/No-Conversation9818 - 1 vote and 9 comments The US Army was not exclusively deployed in Europe during WWII. I never realized how many Marines were there before. Share Add a Comment. So yes marines were thus often using the M1903s, especially in the early months. For a historical account, I'd recommend Ian Toll's Pacific War Trilogy which starts The WW2 museum in New Orleans has this awesome interactive kiosk that you can select any battle during the war and it shows you how many troops were at a specific location, which branch, and what unit it was. It also meant that the best regular Army units were sent to Europe, which meant that the brunt of the fighting in the Pacific would be done by the Marines. More particularly to your question, a Marines gun crew was killed aboard the USS Savannah when it was struck by a German radio-controlled glide bomb while supporting the Salerno Why were there no significant Marine units in the European theater of World War 2? I know about the Marines training the Army for the amphibious assaults in Europe, and the U. Navy and marines fought in pacific because it was island sea and air combat . When the Ichiki Detachment launched the battle of the Tenaru they believed that 1) they were fighting a few thousand marines total 2) said marines were only a reconnaissance in force and 3) that élan would carry the day because it had worked The US Army had more experience with large landings than the Marine Corps (TORCH, HUSKY, SHINGLE), and significantly more forces in Europe on hand than the entire Marine Corps ever had during WW2. So the early M1s tended to go to units heading to Europe. We stationed US Marines all over South America to protect business interests from the 1880s I’m curious how USA involvement is seen from other countries in Europe. So far it's been one of the best WW2 books I've read. Marine officers also were heavily involved in Europe as advisers, observers, specialists, liaisons, and intelligence officers. The Battle of Ortona is one such example, but other significant battles throughout Italy and Northwest Europe involved Canada. That was the main differences between the Marines and the regular Army in the Pacific. Pacific theater though they would have similar small arms with the exception of the johnson rifle as far as I know only used by marines. If you modmail asking for access I'll ban Just be aware that many historians have disputed a lot of Gladwell's conclusions and would not recommend his works for legitimate study. Army and did exist then too. Marines also participated in operations with the Office After World War II and during the 40 year long Cold War that followed with the Soviet Union, U. As the official Marine history Drummer/bugler in the Royal Marines Band Service here. The Royal Marines are part of the Royal Navy. The Marines eventually overcame the defenses on the beach and captured the island by November 23, but it was determined afterward that the pre-invasion bombardment was totally insufficient. It’s also written by non American and non Asian authors so some of the bias you see in other works from these sources is After WW2 ended a point system was put inplace to determine what soldiers would return home first. Army divisions and six Marine divisions. The relocation of a Marine division to Europe would not have had a huge impact on the landings, given the numbers involved, but it would have dramatically slowed In Europe the 97th fought for 41-44 days, suffered some 60% casualties in the first two weeks & near 90% by the end. Texas The Marines in Europe did traditional Marine stuff. The idea being if I have to go, might as well go with the Marines. Marines referred to them as “Teufelshunde” or devil dogs due to their encounters fighting the marines. And the Germans with their long planned before WW2 Generalplan Ost to depopulate Eastern Europe and kill the vast majority of all Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. As a result, you can expect that most of the casualties in the infantry division would be allocated amongst those 4,000 men. Steven White, a Marine Corps intelligence officer and liaison to the 60th Anniversary Commemoration of Operation Union, said the Germans thought the The Marines who implemented this program codified the fundamentals from rifle competitions in Europe and America, and then trained Marines in this manner at recruit training and the entire fleet. The United States Army (including the Army Air Forces), Navy, and the Marine Corps all utilized the same pay scale in WWII. 'Then as we passed them', said the shocked marine, 'I could see they were taking turns raping an oriental woman. But as a rule, George C Marshall was very much oppossed to any Marine combat units fighting in Europe. READ The 1st, 2nd, 3rd, and 4th Marine divisions all made multiple landings, withdrawing entirely from one island before moving on to another. Marching south, men of the 4th Marines passed a group of some 10 American soldiers bunched together in a tight circle next to the road. Was the Army involved in direct combat operations in the pacific? US Army fielded about 89 divisions in WW2, 22 of which fought in the Pacific. Why were the Marines only fighting the Japanese in the Pacific when the U. The idea that Europe during that time was far less racist than the US is deeply wrong, and sadly it is due to a lot of romantisation Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. Army infantry division, much less something like Patton's Army group, but light infantry divisions still exist today in the U. This made me wonder if the Allies or Axis forces used flamethrowers in Europe. Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. The Marines did a fantastic job in WW1, but the mission The Marines were purposely excluded from Europe during World War II and did not play major roles in the largest amphibious invasions in this country's history. 00 ($30. It happens every year at this time: People remember June 6th, 1944, D-Day in Europe, as the be-all-end-all of major invasions of WWII, yet seldom does anyone acknowledge June 15th, 1944, "D-Day in the Pacific" when the United States invaded the Mariana Island chain to crack open the Japanese forces, and open up the other islands to get us to Japan. She was living in Texas and he came through on his way to Europe during WW2. It may have not been formal training in a class room environment, but new technologies being pushed to the front did require troops to master those tools before employment. Meanwhile, u/DBHT14 has addressed the role of the US Army in the Pacific (again, less than It boils down to numbers, the realities of the force, and need or lack thereof. When I was in bootcamp the neanderthals 'teaching' Marine history loved to talk shit on the Navy leaving 1st Mardiv at Guadalcanal but conveniently didn't mention the 1000+ Sailors killed overnight at Savo Island or any of the absolutely desperate battles that took place afterwards Extreme examples of marines are the CCCP marines in ww2. soldiers fought alongside United States embassies had their Marine guards. Army fought in mostly Europe against Nazi Germany and Fascist Italy? Some U. Or check it out in the app stores During WW2 there were 89 U. French artillery opened up on the fort and after two days it was clear that resistance was futile and the Marseille garrison That being said, there was a tacit understanding that the Corps only wanted people who wanted Marines, and they worked with the local draft boards to find draftees who wanted to volunteer for service in the Marines, and as such, while conscripted, many of the draftees had at least explicitly opted for which branch of service they had ended up in. If you are specifically referencing U. The US Marines frequently travel on US Navy ships, and then they go attack stuff on land. For the average Marine coming into the Pacific theater, their pre-conception of the enemy would be formed from the many (exaggerated) stories from combat veterans who had served in previous engagements. In addition to With the Old Breed, you can read Helmet for My Pillow by Robert Leckie which is a 1st person account of the early parts of the Pacific campaigns. As such, they participated in many of the large scale European amphibious assaults, like Hi there -- we have a few older answers on this, mainly focusing on why the USMC was not used in the European theatre. The reason for the jump in WW2 was disinformation, like how the US Army had a 82nd Airborne and 101st Airborne division in Europe and a 17th Airborne Division in the US r/newtothenavy. In some nations mostly European, the "marines" are more like commando forces than for front line combat. In WWII the US Merchant Marines were private ship owners that signed contracts with the US government to transport materials across the ocean for the war. It has all kinds of details for both the Pacific and European theaters, as On the other hand, 40k chaos marines are still organised in legions while loyalists divided themselves into chapters of one thousand marines each. I have read several Vietnam era books with the same idea, Marines talking trash on the rare guy that got drafted. For a case example, the 2nd Marines at Tarawa took about 3,000 casualties out of a force of 18,000 but there's no way that 15,000 marines were needed to garrison Tarawa for the rest of the war. Risler and Bodnar stepped out and the Germans captured the resistance member, Joseph Arcelin. Many of these people were fresh off the boat from Europe without a penny to their name, and the most common line of work in the great cities in the North East was often u/Schaftenheimen has previously answered Why was the United States Marine Corps such a small military branch before 1941?. But it seems reasonable to say that they at least stayed true to the concept of the idea. less than half a million and on the other side of the world. The Marines had roughly 65,000 in the pacific before the Army deployed there in late 1942. If we are talking chaos legions versus loyalist codex chapters we are looking at at least thirty thousand chaos marines versus a maximum of four thousand loyalists. There’s an implication early on that Michael starts out ashamed of his family’s criminal activity (his conversation with Diane Keaton at the wedding), and he likely joined the war to actively try and prove that he was an “honorable” law-abiding good citizen Well I wrote my MA dissertation on the topic of African-American GIs in Britain so hopefully might be able to help. We invaded Mexico under false pretenses and stole 1/3 of their land in 1848. The largest military subreddit on As time went by, Risler would learn just how different “something different” could be: as different as being a Marine in Europe, in a war where most of the Corps battles were taking place in the Pacific; and as different as being one of the few leatherneck paratroopers to actually be airdropped into combat — a rare occurrence during Get the Reddit app Scan this QR code to download the app now. I know flamethrowers were used by the German army during the First World War, and were used by the USMC and USA in the Pacific during World War 2. 11m or so were in the Army/Army Air Forces. suited to the navys strenghts the army fought in europe because it was inland fighting . The American Industrial revolution had happened several decades before ww2. After France fell and the British were pushed out of Western Europe, there was little fighting (outside of Africa) until Germany attacked Russia in 41, prior to the US joining the fight. Marines in Europe were tasked with reinforcing NATO’s northern flank in Norway. Yet some marines in Peleiliu complained the things needed constant cleaning (then again, all guns need that). to help create a mental picture for the reader. For discussion of all things World War II. Movies such as Patton and band of brothers, letters from Iwo Jima etc. The Japanese sank a handful of the LVTs (landing vehicle, tracked) carrying Marines and most of the tanks used in the attack were sunk or knocked out quickly. Or check it out in the app stores U. Reply Well the whole eastern front of the european theatre was a similar meatgrinder, except its Part 1: Since your question is written from the perspective of a Marine, I will try to use a Marine's quotes to answer your question. According to a quick Google, Vietnam saw 42,700 draftees in the Marine Corps of the 448,000 that served between 1965 and 1975, so less than 10%. Perry and so the Germans didn’t execute him. When thinking about U. u/when_ducks_attack has previously explained the role of the Marines in Europe (scroll down for the follow-up answers, this answer is less than six months old) . Marines were garrisoned at Wake Island for example and helped fight the Japanese there (though they lost). 0 coins Reddit iOS Reddit Android Reddit Premium About Reddit Advertise Blog Careers If so, how's it viewed compared to say your nation's Army? Like I know that the British Marines are seen as elite (or were in WW2) and they are trained in arctic warfare as well in This was due to the assumption that black soldiers lacked the mental and physical aptitude for combat that white soldiers possessed. A few Marine planners assisted the Army in planning for Operation Overlord. I’ve deployed under II MEF, nothing but love for my 0311 buddies, but let’s not act like the Army wasn’t pulling much or most of the workload in the Pacific, while handling the WW2 museums in Europe? What are the best museums located in Europe? Countries that I can visit are: Germany, Switzerland, Italy, Austria, Slovenia, Slovakia, Poland, Estonia, Lithuania, Latvia, Czechia and Hungary. As a US Marine 466 votes, 19 comments. The German Navy had a total of 57 submarines, most of which were the smaller Type II coastal boats. The evidence was there that black soldiers Often working behind the scenes with little fanfare and grave personal risk, the Marines of the European Theater embodied the courage, loyalty, and perseverance that have been the hallmark of the Marine Corps The marines were attacking heavily fortified islands, against a very determined enemy. Whereas Marines went and fought a even bigger cult high spirited warriors mastered in banzai charges. Marines with 6th Marine Regiment and 8th Engineer Support Battalion and members of the Ukrainian Armed Forces, pose for a group photo during Exercise Sea Breeze in Ukraine Probably you would have liked US not to get involved in Posted by u/100_stacks - 3 votes and 7 comments Canada's role in WW2 was very significant. There were no major Maine Corps forces used in Europe in WW2. managed its war dead is a 1957 report called "Final disposition of World War II dead, 1945-51," by Edward Steere and M. When the war began, the US Army created 5 Airborne Divisions, and only the 11th was deployed to the Pacific, as well as the 503 Parachute Infantry Regiment. Sort by: We have saved European countries Now, name every landing the Marines conducted singlehandedly. Marines were also on battleships in the Atlantic. Came from fighting in the Pacific in WW2 but the marines have done their best to perpetuate it to this day. They also don't mention that the Navy took more casualties at Guadalcanal than the Marines did too. S ground forces in WWII I usually think the Army in Europe and Marines and Army in the Pacific. gmqslg mbuspokf spf qkclrk hqbshn zpwpca ltvln kiov gkxceqb sel hoip ppll rfjvgpp auaup ziuud